top of page

Challenges Faced by Prevention Practitioners - Part 1

APSI
3 days ago
3 min read

Prevention professionals who deliver evidence-based prevention programming in their communities face many challenges.  Among these challenges are:

 

•      Public distrust of science, misinformation, polarization, and the tendency to favor

appealing narratives over scientific evidence;

•      Issue of Fidelity and Adaptation: Framing Prevention Across Cultural Contexts; and,

•      Being Agnostic When Implementing Evidence-Based Prevention Programs.


This is the first of a three-part Prevention Nugget that will address the first challenge:

 Public distrust of science, misinformation, polarization, and the tendency to favor

appealing narratives over scientific evidence

 


Although the majority of people in the United States trust science, recent studies show that over all, about three-quarters of adults in the United States have confidence in scientists and their effort to work for the public good. For example, a report from the Pew Research Center (2024) indicate that about 76% to 77% of U.S. adults hold either a "great deal" or a "fair amount" of confidence in scientists to act in the public's best interest.  Although this percentage has dropped after COVID, it remains significant. Groups within communities may also vary in their appreciation of science.  Given that evidence-based prevention programming is based on advances in both behavioral science as well as research methodologies, it is important not only for fidelity of implementation but also for credibility that prevention professionals work closely with community members before implementing prevention programming. 

 

The common theme across all of these Prevention Nuggets is involving the community in the implementation of evidence-based prevention programming.


LET’S TALK “SCIENCE”!

 


The scientific methods used to determine the level of effectiveness for prevention programs begin with the development of the program.  Information drawn from observations of large numbers of children and adults and documentation of those factors found to be related to the desired outcomes inform the development of behavioral theories.  These theories are then  tested in a number of groups and if the findings are consistent across groups, they are considered to be valid. The components of these theories are then integrated into the content,  structure, and delivery style of prevention programs. These programs are then subjected to pretesting to assure the content, structure and delivery style are first easily implemented and second have the short-term outcomes desired such as knowledge change.  The next step is to test the programs using rigorous research designs to determine if the desired behavioral outcomes are achieved. The ‘strength’ of that evidence then must be tested using statistical methods that rule out that factors other than the program such as changes in one’s environment or social circumstances are responsible for the positive outcomes. This is accomplished by including a ‘control’ or ‘comparison’ population whose characteristics and social circumstances are similar to that of the population participating in the prevention program.  Furthermore, evaluations of the  implementation of the program with multiple populations, particularly diverse populations, serve to assure that the program is EVIDENCE-BASED!


It is important to emphasize that the science that informs prevention practice is based on working with ‘real’ people representing a cross-section of the general population from beginning to end and always seeking ‘feed-back’ to assure the programs are ready for other populations.

 

Furthermore, many evidence-based prevention programs not only address substance use but also other problematic behaviors.  See Prevention Nugget  June 25, 2025  and the summary chart below. Although the other ‘behaviors’ impacted by the programs vary (depending on whether the study included outcomes other than substance use), most (8) address delinquency and criminal behavior, 7-sexual risk behaviors, 6-conduct problems, 5-emotional regulation, 5-mental health, 5-violence, 4-anxiety, 3-academic performance, 3-aggressive behavior, 3-positive peer relationships, 2-positive parental relationships, 2-bullying, 2-depression, and 2-child maltreatment.  For more information please go to the BluePrints For Healthy Youth Development (https://www.blueprintsprograms.org/).

 


References:

 

 (Pew Research Center, November 2024, “Public Trust in Scientists and Views on Their Role in Policymaking”https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2024/11/PS_2024.11.14_trust-in-science_REPORT.pdf)

 
 
 

Comments


APSI_0.png

419.566.3444

© 2020 Copyright by Applied Prevention Science International (APSI)

bottom of page